Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review)

by Bradley Stern
filed under: Ace of Base, Album Review, Araki, Beyonce, Britney Spears, David Bowie, David LaChapelle, Depeche Mode, Freddie Mercury, Keri Hilson, Lady Gaga, Madonna, Markus Klinko, Pussycat Dolls

fame monster1 Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review)

As Torrance Shipman once said in the 2000 classic, Bring It On, “Missy’s the poo…so take a big whiff.”

While that quote doesn’t really apply here (aside from suggesting that Gaga is indeed ‘the poo’), the point is this: As the driving force behind the writing and recording process of her music, the creative director of her album artwork, music videos, tour visuals, merchandising and just about every other minute facet of her career, Lady Gaga is a very new kind of pop star; one that sings live, writes and records, dances, styles photoshoots, and waxes poetic about the lifestyle of the artiste.

While many have managed to break the market on their own terms, I can’t think of a single mainstream female pop artist in recent times who has exercised nearly as much creative control in both the audio and visual department as Lady Gaga.

In fact, I can’t think of any.

November 23 will see the release of Lady Gaga’s The Fame Monster, an 8-track concept album originally intended to be a re-release of her debut, The Fame. Written as a kind of antithesis to the subject matter of The Fame, The Fame Monster centers around horror and fears–from love, to loneliness, to death.

After some squabbles with her label (and a few inspired writing sessions while out on her Fame Ball Tour), Lady Gaga decided that this newly formed collection of tracks was enough of a living creature in its own right to merit release into the wild all on its own, rather than being slapped onto her pre-existing album. Of course, you could opt to purchase the album as a 2-CD bundle, but as a whole, the record is capable of standing on its own feet–however many feet a monster may have.

Now then, let’s run down the tracklisting.

The Fame Monster begins with “Bad Romance,” the current single that continues to power its way up the radio play charts. Better known as the song of 2009, “Bad Romance” is an unstoppable barrage of catchy hooks, hymn-like chants, and soaring crescendos. It’s a raw, raucous affair, best served at max volume in cars and clubs, and arguably the greatest track that Gaga has ever recorded.  Starting off with such a praise-worthy number, it’s fairly easy to forget that “Bad Romance” is just the first song off of the album.

“Alejandro” comes next, an Ace of Base-like mid-tempo, tropical track. While my reaction to the track was initially lukewarm after hearing the song in demo form, the album’s revamp adds a nice punch to the mix, creating a solid introduction and some reworked vocals. Watch out, though–the repetitive melody is addicting, and you may find that the song’s play count racks up faster than you can say “Alejandro,” “Fernando,” or any other man-of-Latin-origin’s nombre.

“Don’t call me Gaga,” Lady G announces as “Monster” begins to play. At this point, there’s really no need to progress any further into the album, as Gaga’s about to nail it: “Monster” is the epitome of the album’s essence, mashing a killer bass line with cheeky, creature feature lyricism: “We french kissed on a subway train / He tore my clothes right off / He ate my heart, and then he ate my brain,” Gaga laments during the song’s massive, glitchy (perhaps even picopop inspired?) breakdown. It’s a major hit, and is pretty much destined to be an upcoming single sometime soon.

“Speechless,” the next song on the album, comes with plenty of baggage in the Gaga Claims Department over the past few months, with “My favorite song of all” and “The greatest song I ever recorded” being just a few of the quotes offered up by the pop star during interviews. As one might imagine, the song has built a substantial amount of hype.

Mercifully it delivers, and the pay off is rich: “Speechless” is the ’70′s power rock ballad that always been hinted at in her earlier work (“Brown Eyes”, “Again Again”), though never fully realized until now. Penned for her father, “Speechless” is the result of Lady Gaga’s appreciation for the arena-rock legends and glam gods of yore (David Bowie, Freddie Mercury) that avoids imitation and plays like the torch ballad Gaga always needed. It may not be the greatest ‘hit’ of the album, but it is the most aurally adventurous (and surely the most personal). “I’ll never talk again / Oh boy, you’ve left me speechless,” Gaga croons with a swagger hitting somewhere between classic Elton John and Liza Minnelli. Concertgoers, be prepared–this one’s made for the lighters-in-the-air moment.

Coming in thereafter is “Dance in the Dark,” the album’s chilliest moment. “Silicone, saline, poison, inject me / Baby, I’m a free bitch,” Gaga scowls at the song’s beginning, which happens to double as the greatest opening line of the year. A hands-in-the-air dance song about a woman being harassed by her boyfriend, Gaga’s “Dance” is a murderous slice of pop complete with industrial whirls, haunted synths and occasional screams of anguish in the distance.

Part of the songs appeal, aside from being as danceable as it is dark (thus, “Dance in the Dark”…get it, eh?), lies in its occasional nods to the classics–from the  pulsating injection of Depeche Mode‘s “Strangelove” into the opening chords to its homage to Madonna‘s “Vogue” throughout the song’s spoken word middle eight:  “Marilyn, Judy, Sylvia…tell ‘em how you feel, girls!”

However unlike Madge’s celebrity roll-call, Gaga limits her subjects according to theme, choosing only those who’ve suffered a tragic end by way of, or indirectly because of, the fame. By the end of it all, you’ll want to know only one thing: Who knew emotional abuse could inspire such happy feet?

The next track, “Telephone,” is a doozy–a duet with Beyonce? Even on print, you’re already asking for trouble. “Telephone” was originally penned and serviced to Britney Spears by Gaga, rejected, and then reclaimed by the writer herself.

Along with a beat recalling Timbaland‘s “The Way I Are” and a frantic, stuttering electro-bass line, “Telephone” is a mish-mosh of synths, phone sounds and above all, rampant telephone talk. While Beyonce’s vocal runs are a welcome addition to the track, the song functions best as an unapologetic celebration of the vocoder. Just dance, as someone around here might say.

“So Happy I Could Die” seems to pick up where The Fame‘s “Starstruck” left off, borrowing its squeaky synthesizers and urban flavoring to engage in some self-indulgence. “In the silence of the night, through all the tears and all the lies / I touch myself and its alright.” While some reviews have likened the track to Britney Spears‘ “Touch of My Hand,” the music and lyrics seem far too dark to place “Happy” in the same realm as Spears’ ode to self-exploration. As the verses fade, the unusual anti-chorus fills the void: “Happy in the club with a bottle of red wine / Stars in our eyes ’cause we’re having a good time / Yeah, yeah / So happy I could die.”

Minimal and moody, “Happy” provides food for the mind while moving back and forth between Gaga and an unidentified “she.” It could be herself she’s referencing, but I’m still uncertain. Sasha Gaga, perhaps?

“Teeth,” the album’s premature closer, takes a surprising turn in sound: A stomping, hoot-and-holler-worthy chant-along, the final track of The Fame Monster invites listeners to cut loose and…well, sink their teeth into the music. Part musical, part country, and a little bit tribal in spots, Gaga snarls and taunts above an incessant, stomping march: “Take a bite of my bad girl meat / Show me your teeth.”  It’s an odd choice to end the album, though a surefire crowd pleaser for live shows if the addictive backing beat is anything to judge by.

Out of the eight excellent tracks of the album, the greatest part about listening to The Fame Monster is not the catchy beats or silly lyrics (of which there are many), or even the lock of Gaga’s own hair included with the Super Deluxe Fan Edition (with which I still have no idea what to do with)–it’s the fact that the album is history in the making.

For better or worse, Gaga is on the path of legendary status:  With only one album under her belt, Lady Gaga has already broken a world record for most #1 singles from a debut album, written for Britney Spears, Keri Hilson and the Pussycat Dolls, collaborated with high-profile photographers and artists including David LaChapelle, Araki, and Markus Klinko (which is not to forget her sheer influence on the runway, as well as scoring the devotion from runway legends like Alexander McQueen and Marc Jacobs). Along the way, she’s performed across the world to millions from San Francisco to Jerusalem, including a recent concert in New York where a newfound fan named Madonna watched along with her daughter, Lourdes, in the audience.

While I may be prone to hyperbole, I do believe that The Fame Monster is without a doubt the pop album of the year, if not one of the finest pop records of the decade.

And to think, this was just going to be a re-release.

onemuurating Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review) onemuurating Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review) onemuurating Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review) onemuurating Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review) onemuurating Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review)

Pre-Order The Fame Monster from Lady Gaga’s Official Store | Buy tickets to The Monster Ball Tour | MySpace | Official Website

pixel Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Album Review)

  • http://www.ademwithane.com/ Adem With An E

    What an ace review. TFM seems to be really inspiring a lot of pop bloggers to write some really brilliant-to-read reviews of the record.

    That bit at the end I loved too; about how this was almost just going to be a re-release. It’s funny; 8 tracks and yet it’s more than enough of an album for me. Quality over Quantity…

  • vicente

    Thank you.. i loved it
    atte. a fan

  • vicente

    but idk why you forgot to review telephone.. odd..
    atte. a fan

  • http://twitter.com/sedriddick sedo

    Teeth as the album closer seems like a taste of better things to come, of what her next sound’s gonna be like. Can’t wait.

  • http://mariecurie.biz Marie Curie

    wow, thanks, I love laga

  • http://twitter.com/sedriddick sedo

    Yeah, wait, how come there’s no Telephone?

  • http://www.muumuse.com Bradley Stern

    Whoops–must have forgotten to write about “Telephone” because of the review two days ago. Thanks for reminding me, guys! Added :)

  • http://www.shanparker.com Shan

    I’d say Teeth is the album closer because it’s kinda of the odd man out, a sound that doesn’t fit with the rest quite as well, typically how a lot of album tracklists are composed. This review was spot on, and I agree with the comment about quality over quantity. I’d rather have an 8 track album that I don’t have to skip half the tracks for the good ones.

  • http://www.myradeo.com Aneto

    Great review. Gaga has been burning up the charts. Thanks for sharing. I found your blog while searching for something.

    Since its relevant here and you might find it fun/useful. I also wanted to give a plug for a site Ive been working on that helps people share songs with their friends. Its built on top of Facebook and Youtube.

    http://www.myradeo.com Its free, easy and there’s no account signup. Login with Facebook. Check it out if you get a chance. Hope you like it. Thanks!

  • http://fabtasticmusic.blogspot.com Aaron

    Fantastic! I can’t wait to get my hands on this one, sounds AMAZING!

  • http://marcusleepowers.blogspot.com Marcus

    I agree with this review. I was somewhat lukewarm when it came to Lady GaGa’s debut album. I liked Poker Face and Paparazzi, but I wasn’t really blown away by anything else.

    However, this new stuff is pretty epic and brilliant. She’s done an excellent job of capturing a moment in time. I think that years down the line, I’ll think of 2009 and I’ll think of this album.

  • david

    spot on… i feel like we “grew in to gaga” at the exact same time!

  • http://leeloveshottrends.com/ LeeAnn

    I think this album is going to be a good buy, thanks to your review. Lady GaGa is amazing. She dresses weird but ever since she came, Rihanna and all the other celebrities are trying to compete against her when it comes to fashion. But no one can beat the fame monster.

  • http://www.a1charts.blogspot.com a1

    she is the new Madonna, period.

  • http://rcloy.blogspot.com rcloy

    Impressive review. Definitely the best pop album of the year! :D

  • http://j.busson@yahoo.com Thanks for the brilliant, in-depth review. Just what I was looking for!
  • Pingback: Hot One New Music Review – Lady Gaga’s The Fame Monster (11/23) | Hot-Music-Releases.com: The Blog Edition

  • Lily

    awesome x

  • HatlessHessian

    Not only does Dance in the Dark channel DM’s Strangelove, but the chord progression is right out of Wham!’s “Careless Whisper.” I’d kill for a mix with Strangelove and Wham!’s sax solo thrown in.

  • i love gagag

    colkloll

  • Brad the Dad

    Yo.
    I am a musician. I am a music lover. I love Madonna, Michael Jackson, but also love Coltrane, Wes Montgomery, Louis Armstrong, Classical symphonic Orchestra recordings, Guns N Roses, AC/DC, Indigo Girls, Beach Boys, Living Colour, The Melvins, TOOL, and many many more.
    I saw one Lady Gaga video, and then her SNL performance, and was excited to buy the album ‘The Fame Monster’ and share it with my children and my wife!
    My wife warned me that she thought my judgement had flown the coop, but I persisted that GAGA struck me as an intelligent, empowering female, with great musical abilities, and that the album would show this.

    Umm,
    NO.
    This album is absolutely one of the largest meltdown letdowns of the last three decades.
    Nowhere in this album is there a sound that produces a reaction in me that says, ‘Wow, they put some effort into this.’
    In fact,
    My six-year old has created a plethora of more unique, talented, ear-loving catchy tunes with her radio-shack keyboard and her voice alone.

    Lady Gaga,
    you owe me one, big time,
    and I’m not talking about sex, baby. My wife does that thing with me all day and all night for realz,
    not with a damn disco stick- (whatever that is).

    You best take this money,
    fire every human involved in this album,
    head to L.A. or even Kansas City,
    find a bass player, a drummer, a guitar player,
    and perhaps a synth-keyboard master,
    get a new producer,
    and write some songs with some real emotion.

    You remind me of someone who has had their soul scared out of them,
    and now only lives to prove to the world that
    nothing much matters to you anymore.

    You dont empower anyone or anything,
    except your wallet.

    And, Lady-
    even in America- that will NOT BE GOOD ENOUGH
    over the long haul.
    I surmise all the males who ‘love’ her ‘album’(parenthesized because it has no musical qualities),
    are all secretly pedophiles,
    or worse.

    If you dont own up to the community, Lady Gaga,
    I suggest you find a new day job.

    I am very disappointed in you,
    we put a lot of faith in you,
    that you would knock our socks off.

    Instead,
    you have pissed off the all-knowing consciousness,
    and will be punished accordingly.
    Prepare to bend over.

  • Robbi

    OMG!!!!! I just got THE FAME MONSTER for Christmas and it ROCKS!!!!!!!! its is one of the best albums i have ever heard in my life!!! BUY IT if you DONT HAVE IT!!!

  • WESLEY G

    LADY GAGA,S THE FAME MONSTER ROCKS BIG TIME. i love the way its produced with such dexterous style and sense. its THE POP ALBUM OF THE YEAR. AND 2010 BELONGS TO GAGA. I CANT CHOOSE A FAVOURITE SONG AMONGST IT AS THEY ALL ARE GAGALICIOUS.

  • Pingback: Hollywood Gossip, Lady GaGa Tickets – the New Lady in Town | Lady Gaga Albums Guidelines & Toolbox